Dialogues
Does Hinduism exist?
Is ‘Hinduism’ a ‘religion’? dharma, transcendence and the
‘human sciences’
Is Hindutva a ‘legitimate’ expression of ‘Hinduism’?
Religion, nationalism and the ‘secular’ Indian state
Future of Hindu-Christian relations: a Dialogue about
dialogue!
FRIENDS
Al Collins is a clinical psychologist by day who wears out his mental dancing
shoes at night reading Sanskrit and psychoanalysis and writing about the wonders
he finds there. His Indology Ph.D. at Texas (with Rao, Lehman, Polome, and Katre)
was on the origins of the classical Brahman (e.g., purohita) - King relationship.
He was a friend, student, and teaching assistant of the novelist Raja Rao (The
Serpent and the Rope, Kanthapura). Al and his wife Elaine have their website
at www.BrainDance.us. His occasional
blog is at www.naham.blogspot.com.
Perhaps the best way to get to know him would be through his recent Dharmamegha
paper below on Indian culture theory as he is beginning to see it.
Al has been a member of the Abhinavagupta forum since 09 Sep 2007, and became
an active contributor to the discussions in March 2009 with his post on the
DANAM/AAR panel he was putting together on "Perspectives of traditional Indian
culture theory on contemporary media cultures."
Born in Madrid, Spain, in 1953, Alvaro Enterr�a, traveled to India for the first
time in the year 1981. He subsequently made many other trips until 1989 when
he remained in Benares (Varanasi) for a stay of two years from which he did
not return. In the sacred city, he got married to an Indian wife and started
a family. He also founded, together with his Indian partner, Dilip Kumar
Jaiswal, the �ndica Books imprint in Benares.
Indica Books (publishing-house
and bookshop in Benares)
The bookshop threw its
doors open to the public on 3rd November 1994, the day of Diwali, the Hindu
"Festival of Lights." Situated in the heart of the city, this bookshop
consists, after a recent expansion, of two stories and specializes in
Indology. It boasts of ample sections devoted to Hinduism, Buddhism, Tantra,
Yoga, philosophy, art and music, Ayurveda, astrology, etc. Although the
majority of the books are in English, it also has sections in Sanskrit and
Hindi, as well as others in Spanish, French and other languages. �ndica
Books regularly publishes books in English, Hindi and Sanskrit for the
Indian market on themes of Indian culture and philosophy, as well as on the
city of Benares. In collaboration first with Etnos, and presently with the
publisher Ola�eta, Palma de Mallorca, �ndica Books also publishes books in
Spanish on Indian themes. The Indica Books website (www.indicabooks.com) has
a wide offering of India-related books in English and Spanish, as well as
sections on culture, photography, travel, etc.
Antonio de
Nicolas
Antonio T. de Nicolas was
born in Villalaco (Palencia, Spain), and
educated in Spain, India and the United States, where he
received his Ph.D. in philosophy at Fordham University in New York. He is
currently Professor Emeritus of philosophy at the
State University of New York at Stony Brook, Long Island,
New York and Director of the Center for Biocultural Studies in Florida.
Antonio is the author of some 27 books in English
and numerous articles, particularly the book Avat�ra:
The Humanization of Philosophy through the Bhagavad G�t�
and
Meditations Through the Rig Veda,
both
classics in the field of Indic studies; and
Habits of Mind: An Introduction to Clinical Philosophy, a criticism of higher education, whose framework
has recently been adopted as the educational system for the new Russia
and in seven states in the USA. He is also known for his acclaimed
translations of the poetry of the Nobel Prize-winning author, Juan Ramon Jimenez, and of the mystical
writings of St. Ignatius de Loyola and St.
John of the Cross.
A philosopher by profession,
Antonio confesses that his most abiding
philosophical concern is the act of imagining that
he has pursued in his studies of the Spanish mystics, Eastern classical texts
and, most recently, in his own poetry. His books of poetry: Remembering the God to Come, The Sea Tug
Elegies, Of Angels and Women, Mostly,
and
Moksha Smith: Agni's Warrior-Sage (An Epic of the
Immortal Fire), have received wide acclaim.
Critical reviewers of these works have offered the following insights.
From Choice: "these poems could not
have been produced by a mainstream American. They are illuminated from
within by a gift, a skill, a mission...unlike the critico-prosaic American
norm"
From The Baltimore Sun: "Steeped as
they are in mythology and philosophy these are not easy poems. Nor is de
Nicolas an easy poet. He confronts us with the necessity to remake our
lives...his poems...show us that we are not bound by rules. Nor are we bound
by mysteries. We are bound by love. And therefore, we are boundless" From
William Packard, editor of the New York Quarterly: "This is the kind
of poetry that Plato was describing in his dialogues, and the kind of poetry
that Nietzsche was calling for in Zarathustra."
A
world of rapid experience ...traveler, poet, author
Having finished school in
India, Ashok Chowgule went to the UK in Jan 1965 to do his
Cambridge Advanced level (pre-university) examinations
and then to graduate in Economics. Later he went to
the USA to take up business studies. Upon completion,
he joined the family business (iron ore mining, ship building, shipping,
industrial explosives, etc.) in Goa. Subsequently, in 1980, he moved to Mumbai
to look after a cement plant, primarily promoted by the family. This plant was
sold in 1999, and since then Ashok Chowgule is in Goa looking after the ship
building unit.
Being aware of the need to
contribute to the socio-political development in India, he has taken keen
interests in the current affairs of India. However, he was disenchanted with the
way things were happening, particularly after the failure of Shri Rajiv Gandhi
to live up to the promises of his early days in politics. In search
of an alternative, he came across some leaders of the
Sangh Parivar (family of organizations seeking to mobilize
Hindus towards social reform). During the initial interactions, he felt
that solutions to the problems confronting the country could be found
within the parameters of Hindutva. It was in this context that he read Dr.
Koenraad Elst's book Ayodhya and After, which cleared many of the issues
that he found puzzling. He was now able to see how the intellectuals in India
were perverting the debate within society. Right from the beginning of his contact with
the Sangh Parivar, he decided to work for the Vishwa Hindu Parishad
(VHP) and is passionate about the Shri Ram Janmabhoomi movement, which he
sees as one that transcends the mere bricks and mortar angle. He is presently
the President of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad for Maharashtra,
and has contributed many articles to present the VHP perspective in many
matters.
This article was originally published
in The Organiser, January 3rd, 1994.
Dialogues: Hinduism a Religion?
Currently Associate Professor of English, College of Vocational Studies,
University of Delhi, Bharat Gupt was born in 1946 in Moradabad but went to school
in Delhi, where he studied English, Hindi, Sanskrit and philosophy. He spent
a year in the US at the end of Counter-Cultural days and took a Master's degree
from Toronto. He learnt to play the sitar and surbahar under the eminent musician
Uma Shankar Mishra and studied musicology, yoga sutras and classics under Acarya
Brihaspati and Swami Kripalvananda. Trained both in modern European and traditional
Indian educational systems, he has worked in classical studies, theatre, music,
culture and media studies and researched as Senior Onassis Fellow in Greece
on revival of ancient Greek theatre. On the visiting faculty at the National
School of Drama, Delhi and the Bhartendu Academy for Dramatic Arts , Lucknow,
Bharat has lectured on theatre and music at various Universities in India, North
America and Greece His practical involvement with traditional Indian temple
architecture resulted in initiating the
construction
of a "nagar style" stone temple with carvings which will give
Delhi a traditional temple after a millennium. His published books are:
Dramatic
Concepts Greek and Indian (1994) and
Natyashastra,
Chapter 28: Ancient Scales of Indian Music (1996). I write for research
journals and national newspapers also on cultural and educational issues. His
forthcoming books are: (1) Natyasastra, Chapter 17: A Critique of Theatrical
Polyglossia, (2) Natyasastra Chapters 29-36 , Trans. into Hindi,
(3) Dibbuk Ki Prem Katha, a translation into Hindi of Anskey's Dibbuk.
(4) Modern Greek Productions of Ancient Greek Plays, and (5) the first
Edition of the Sanskrit-English-Greek Dictionary of Demitrios Galanos,
the eighteenth century Greek Indologist, and (6) India: A Cultural Decline
or Revival.
Carl is the author of
Towards Truth: An Australian Spiritual Journey (Sydney: Pacific Press,
1992). He is also the editor of Bhakti! newsletter published in Canberra.
A participant-scholar of Murugan worship in Malaysia and India, Carl is
completing his doctorate at Deakin University in Australia. I discovered Carl
through a Google search in 2000 on "transgressive sacrality," and learnt to my
pleasant surprise that the insights that I've attempted to conceptualize are
being applied in unexpectedly productive ways to the religious anthropology of
my country of birth. All the more so because, for several years after the award
of my doctorate in B.H.U., I had been struggling in vain to join the
Indian/Tamil Studies Dept. at the Universiti Malaya, which was keen to take me
but found it impossible to circumvent the civil service requirement that
permanent appointees have at least a basic (Bachelors) degree from Malaysia. It
is therefore personally gratifying to note how Carl has been working closely
with my would-be Malaysian colleagues like Dr. Raymond Lee.
This talk, that Carl
gave during his visit to Malaysia/Singapore in
February 2004 for his 13th participation in Thaipusam, is
based on a 80-page essay derived from doctoral work
Originally written for a
Melbourne-based journal, this review of Ritual Power and Moral
Redemption among Malaysian Hindus
was blocked by an academic (apparently close to Collins) on the editorial
panel, who had once written that kavadi worship was no part of the
Murugan tradition and was unknown in India! For a more thorough debunking of
an even worse "run away" example of "wild (psycho-) analysis," see Kali's
Child Revisited or Didn't Anyone Check the Documentation? by Swami
Tyagananda
Thai Pusam in Malaysia - (First International Conference on
Skanda-Murukan) - abstract
I was born and still live in
La Paz, the capital of Bolivia. I think my life was
linked to India from the
beginning, when I saw in
one of my children magazines–I
was four years old then–a
wheel with the picture of a seated man: it was the Buddha turning the
Wheel of Dharma. As a teenager,
I was a fan of yoga, trying to perform the postures (�sana) as best I could in search of health.
Then, I discovered Krishna, the Bhagavad Gita,
and devotion to God. Many years later after an
abortive career in electronic engineering,
I studied history here in La
Paz. I was practicing Buddhist meditation in my
courtyard and suddenly the thought came to me: " Why
don't you study History?" I left mathematics aside for social science. I was fortunate in my new career
where I won recognition three times as
the best student of History at the University of San
Andr�s: the first was the
Guido Capra Award for Excellence,
the next from the Honorable Facultative Council on
Humanities, and then the Honor's Diploma from the
Major University of San Andr�s. Currently working on my
thesis on Buddhism in Bolivia
towards a B. A. degree, I am writing
on the web, researching
articles, and discussing in cyber-forums
my passion: India.
Chitra, who could
say of herself: “I am, therefore I write,” began writing poetry and reflective
soliloquies between the ages of 7 and 10. At age 12, when
still a seventh grader in Bhubaneswar, Orissa, she won first prize in a
national essay-writing contest. A year later, she moved to Delhi when her father
obtained a posting there. Her reticence for public speaking is matched by her
passion for the assumed role. Chitra’s adventures on the Delhi stage
began with a school adaptation of the musical “The King and I” which landed her
radio interviews with the BBC and the Voice of America. She subsequently
acted in several plays with the theater groups Yatrik and Masque. Chitra
immigrated to the United States in 1985, bringing with her seven years of
professional writing experience. Her lovely and musically talented daughter
Divya was born on Valentines Day, 1991. That year, Chitra enrolled in Wayne
State University for a second Bachelor’s degree in Journalism.
Though her life turned into uncharted waters when Divya was diagnosed
with autism in 1993, she graduated with honors. She resolved to focus like
a laser on helping her daughter overcome her limitations, and to continue to
write freelance. Chitra’s writings span fundraising proposals, articles on
special education topics, poetry, book reviews, opinion editorials, satire,
children’s stories, research papers, and reflective essays.
She serves on a strategic planning committee formed to advise the
Michigan State Department of Education of best practices for the education of
children on the Autism spectrum. She also works
on an ongoing basis with her local school district on adapting the science
curriculum for different learners.
See Chitra's
unabridged autobiographical note).
Commentary;
India Abroad;
January 21, 2005, Pg. A22.
The Battle of Kurukshetra; The Legs of the
Tortoise. By Maggi Lidchi-Grassi. Roli Books, 1996, pp.
368 and 350. See also the
book review
by Pradip Bhattacharya.
Samvad: The IndDiaspora Experience,
World Association for Vedic Studies Fifth International Conference,
July 9-11, 2004
"India’s Intellectual Traditions in Contemporary Global Context". Chitra's feminism paper was
presented as part of a symposium on the e-group IndDiaspora.
As such, it embeds exchanges from that
e-group within the larger universe of issues covered by the paper. The
symposium featured other presentations including the IndDiaspora debate on
Dowry by Dr. Beloo Mehra, Hindu-American Identity by Aditi Banerjee,
and a talk about how the concept of IndDiaspora took shape, by founder Harsh
Verma. Symposium
details, Appendix 1:
"My
Distant Aunt…and I"
by Jayshree Misra Tripathi;
Appendix 2: "Silence"
by Anasuya Sengupta, Appendix 3: "Moving
Beyond Words" by Gloria Steinem.
Written originally for
Thomson Gale "years ago,"
bits and pieces of the information in this
article were pulled out and plugged it into different online
products. The essay has been published for the first
time in its pristine form here
David Dubois
David Peter Lawrence
David's research areas include comparative
philosophy as a mode of inter-cultural and inter-religious dialogue, the
Pratyabhijna philosophy of monistic Kashmiri Saivism, and related areas of
Hinduism and Buddhism.
Recently he has been particularly interested in monistic Saiva approaches to identity and the body; and Abhinavagupta's legacy
of using Pratyabhijna categories to interpret nonphilosophical tantric
symbolism and practice. His publications include
Rediscovering God with Transcendental Argument: A Contemporary Interpretation
of Monistic Kashmiri Saiva Philosophy (SUNY, 1999). David received his BA from George Washington University
(GWU), and his MA and PhD from the University of Chicago (1992). He has
taught in the Division of Humanities of the Hong Kong University of Science
and Technology and the Department of Religion of Concordia University,
Montreal. He is now a visiting associate professor in the Department of
Religion of the University of Manitoba. With
regards to mentors, David's graduate school advisors were Wendy Doniger,
Paul Griffiths, Bimal Krishna Matilal and David Tracy. He first visited
India from 1987-1989, where he studied monistic Saivism mainly with Hemendra
Nath Chakravarty in Varanasi and Navjivan Rastogi at
Lucknow University. He also studied monistic Saivism and related areas of
Sanskritic philosophy with other scholars including Srinarayan Mishra and
Radheshyam Chaturvedi of Banaras Hindu University. He has since visited
India for several shorter trips to work with Pt. Chakravarty, Prof. Rastogi
and Prof. Mishra.
"The Visuvalingams extended great hospitality and
support to me during my
first visit to Varanasi. They helped me to get settled
into the city and introduced me to some of its
cultural and spiritual riches. At that time, their home was a magnetic center
for a number of interesting scholars of monistic Saivism and other areas of
Hinduism. I am delighted to have renewed
our friendship and to participate in the Abhinavagupta
website."
David looked us up on his arrival in Benares in 1987 at the suggestion of our
friend Alf Hiltebeitel (his ex-teacher at GWU). I recall several passionate
discussions with David about Trika philosophy in our BHU apartment, and we also
got to meet his father when the latter first visited him in the sacred city.
Though David briefly visited us in Boston, in the early 90s after we had moved
from India, we lost touch during his years in Hong Kong. We were delighted to
renew our friendship after his well-received talk on "Concepts of Empowered
Identity and Tradition in Medieval Monistic Shaivism" at the Chicago University
South Asia Watch panel on Religion and Identity in Kashmir (9 April
2004). We had been impressed from the very beginning by David's personal—and
clearly ongoing—attempt
to engage Abhinava not as a mere curiosity from an obsolete Indian past but on
account of his relevance to burning issues in contemporary philosophical and
religious thought.
Foreword to Danger! Educated Gypsy: Selected Essays by Ian Hancock (November
2010)
Ian Hancock, Danger! Educated Gypsy: Selected
Essays, edited by Dileep Karanth (University Of Hertfordshire
Press, 01 November 2010), 288 pages. ISBN-10: 1902806999, ISBN-13:
978-1902806990.
"My teacher, Professor Ian F. Hancock, is an unusual man: unusual in his
background, in the breadth of his interests and in the range of his
accomplishments. He was the first Gypsy to be awarded a doctorate in the UK; he
is perhaps the only person to hold three doctorates without having finished high
school. His book The Pariah Syndrome – the first to document the
enslavement of Roma in Europe – came as a revelation to those who were
accustomed to think of slavery as an institution restricted in modern times only
to Europe’ colonies. Another of his books, We Are the Romani People, also
the first of its kind, has become an authoritative source for teachers who wish
to present the Romani self-statement to their students. Author of over 350
publications, esteemed teacher to generations of students and tireless spokesman
for the Romani peoples of the world, Ian has achieved much fame and even some
notoriety in his eventful lifetime. This collection of select writings is an
attempt to introduce this dangerously educated and educating man through
the medium of his work. Within its covers you will find poetry and song,
stories and scholarship, bitter criticisms and friendly advice."
Dileep Karanth, "Hindu-Buddhist Conflict in the Chachnama: Fact or Fiction?"
History Today (Journal of History and Historical Archaeology) No. 9, 2008, pp.
49-52
Amir Khusrau's Contributions to Indian Music: a preliminary survey (2008)
Amir Khusrau's Contributions to Indian Music: A Preliminary Survey by Dileep
Karanth Sangeet Natak, Vol. XLII, Number 4, 2008, pages 3-14. Sangeet Natak is a journal of music, dance and drama published since 1965 by
Sangeet Natak Akademi -- the National Academy of Music, Dance and Drama.
The Unity of India (2003-2004)
Felix and I originally met during the 'First' World Humor Conference in
Hyderabad in 198?, where we spoke on humor in
Spanish and Sanskrit
literature respectively. I subsequently invited him
from Jawaharlal Nehru University (Delhi), where he was teaching Spanish, to
lecture at the English and Philosophy Depts. at BHU. F�lix had lived in
Madras and Gujarat from ? to ? studying (Gujarati and) Indian traditions. On
our first visit to America in Dec. 85, we were received royally by the
Ilarraz', the whole humanities program at Indiana State University (ISU),
and by the Indian community at Terre Haute. Their proximity was a decisive
factor in my taking up the computer publishing job in Indianapolis in Nov.
1993. On retiring to Madrid in 199?, after having
taught Spanish and Indian philosophy at ISU for
over 30 (?) years, F�lix
has continued to further the cause of Indian culture in the West, for
example, through significant contributions to the endowment of the Tagore
Chair in Bloomington. Back in Madrid, he assumed active direction of the
Purusha Foundation dedicated to promoting
knowledge of Indian (and other) tradition(s) in Spain. Their
generous hospitality in Dec-Jan. 2000-01
and again in summer of 2001 allowed us to discover
the cultural riches of the Iberian peninsula. Hailing from a family
of
Jesuit priests, F�lix is
himself a product of its rigorous discipline. His
sister has lived most of her life as a Carmelite nun among the poor of the
slums of Bombay.
The Castes of India - published in Spanish in the Sarasvati journal
Introduction to book on Indian Philosophy (with Oscar Pujol Riembau)
Francesco Brighenti
Francesco Brighenti (born in Venice, Italy, 1963) has
travelled extensively in India in pursuit of his academic
interest in the living traditions of Hinduism and their relation to
tribal cultures. Having worked on the goddess-cults of Orissa
(1995-97), he received his
Ph.D. from the Utkal University, Bhubaneswar. His
doctoral
thesis was subsequently expanded into a book (Shakti
Cult in Orissa, New Delhi, D.K. Printworld, 2001). As a member of the
Venetian Academy of Indian Studies—an association of Indologists
with close ties with the Department of East Asian
Studies, Ca’ Foscari University, Venice, Italy— Francesco has been
researching the religious practices
of
different Scheduled Tribes of eastern India in reelation to
the regional typologies of Hindu cults. In particular, he has
done field work in the areas of Orissa populated by
the Kondhs and in those of Jharkhand populated by the Mundas. His main
concern
has been to detect the religio-cultural parallels
between the tribal and the Hindu traditions
of human- and buffalo-sacrifice. The
results are embodied in two essays. The first one,
entitled "Traditions of Human Sacrifice in Ancient and Tribal India and
Their Relation to Sh�ktism," will appear soon in Breaking Boundaries with the Goddess: New
Directions in the Study of Sh�ktism. Essays in
Honor of Narendra Nath Bhattacharyya, ed. by Rachel McDermott and Cynthia
Humes (under contract with Manohar Publishers, New Delhi). The second essay,
on buffalo-sacrifice, is available below.
Another line of research pursued
by Francesco is the rootedness in older shamanistic
practices of some 'low'
Hindu cult practices, viz. Shaiva/Sh�kta
devotional ordeals such as fire-walking,
hook-swinging, cheek-piercing, walking or swinging on thorns or nails, the
transport of k�vadi,
etc., are discussed in this
still unpublished essay in Italian (that he has translated
here for svAbhinava). The likely Hindu mythical
archetypes of such ritual ordeals
are also touched upon in this essay.
An extract from Francesco's second essay, written in
Italian and still unpublished, that discusses the
sacrifices of bovines (especially water-buffaloes) performed by a large
number of tribal populations of South and Southeast Asia in connection with
their respective mortuary ceremonies.
The conclusions
of the AIT/OIT debate—provided they are accepted
as incontrovertible by the vast majority of scholars—will
no doubt serve as the basis for
new directions in Indological studies
in the 21st century. To confront the contrasting opinions expressed
by scholars in the course of this crucial debate,
Francesco collected a
huge database of e-books, e-articles and
messages posted at Internet forums, that has now been
kindly placed at the disposal of anyone attempting
to form their own opinion. I received this web-directory on 10 Nov. 2003 and
posted it the following day.
Dr. Gautam Sen has taught international political economy to graduate students
for two decades at the London School of Economics & Political Science. He
has published widely on the political economy of development, international
trade issues, defence economics and India in scholarly journals as well as
newspapers, including the London Times, Economic and Political Weekly, The Pioneer and The
Indian Express. He has recently co-authored a book on trade, money
and investment and is now working on a study of how some societies come to
be dominated by more successful ones. He was born in Varanasi, grew up in
Calcutta and has lived in England for the past 35 years. Dr.
Sen has been an adviser to the Prime Ministers of India and Nepal and is a
member of the eminent person’s group of the Indo-UK Roundtable.
"Apart from being born there my personal connections with Benares are a little
sporadic because we left to live in Calcutta very soon afterwards. But I did
visit regularly, including a particularly memorable trip when I ran away to
the city as a 14 year-old schoolboy. Having caught a train from Howrah
[Calcutta railway station] I spent an enchanting
fortnight (living with my grandmother In Jangambari) roaming the streets and
ghats freely, visiting ancient (mainly religious) sites and rowing
across the Ganges single-handedly every other day. I can't imagine how I
dared hire a boat and engage in this risky activity! My father graduated
with a degree in metallurgy from BHU in the early 1940s when Radhakrishnan
was vice chancellor. Most people don't know that BHU was the premier
institution of India for engineering and some science subjects before
independence. It was very hard to gain admission into BHU in the 1930s and
hardly 25% survived my father's cohort into the second year because the
maths was too demanding! My grandfather-in-law, the late Raj Guru Hem Raj
Pandey of Nepal, a renowned Sanskrit scholar, also had strong ties with
Benares (with a majestic house in the city), which is where his books are
still available, rather than in Nepal."
Dr. (Rai Bahadur) Dinesh Chandra Sen,
Gautam's great grandfather, donated his extraordinary collection of books
and vast hoard of original ancient manuscripts to the Royal Asiatic Society
of Bengal (his
own books and manuscripts formed a significant
collection within it). It was he who built up the Department of Bengali
Language and Literature of the University of Calcutta.
The section on tantric practices, while describing the Temples of
Birbhum, is from Dinesh Chandra's two-volume History of
Bengali
Language and
Literature (Eng. 1911;
Bengali 1898;
cf. pp. 8-9 ). Gautam recently heard that books and manuscripts from
the collection were being sold for a few rupees on the footpath
outside—the establishment is under the control of
communist trade unions.
Ian Whicher is a professor in
religion at the University of Manitoba. His interests include the religious
and philosophical thought of India, Hinduism, the Yoga Tradition. He is the
author of The Integrity of the Yoga Darsana: A Reconsideration of
Classical Yoga (SUNY 1998). I got to know Ian through
our exchanges on the draft of his paper on "Countering World Negation"
(below) even before we got to meet at the Indic Colloquium in July 2002.
Since we shared the long ride back to Albany airport, where we also had to
wait together for our respective flights, we had much time to discuss Indian
spirituality, the relationship between Sri Aurobindo and Abhinavagupta,
Ian's planned sabbatical in Europe, etc.
This paper, presented to the Indic Colloquium (2002),
challenges interpretations of Yoga that have misrepresented Patanjali's
philosophical outlook as being radically dualistic, isolationistic, and
world-denying. Drawing from classical texts, it will be argued that Yoga is
a balanced integration of the spiritual and material dimensions of
life/self. Yoga does not advocate the abandonment or condemnation of the
world but rather supports a stance that enables one to live more fully in
the world without being enslaved by worldly identification. Yoga can be seen
thus to incorporate a clarity of awareness with the integrity of being and
action. The final version has been published in Evam
3:1 & 2 (2004), pp.38-54.
Jacqueline and Roland Bouchet
Roland and Jacqueline are
the parents of
ChristianBouchet. Jacqueline had done her Ph.D. in English Literature at the
Sorbonne on (the theme of the 'foreigner' in) George Eliot (pen-name of Mary Ann
Evans). Roland had been responsible for setting up the IT networks in several
departments of the French academic establishment, including the Sorbonne. They
are also in charge of the Center for Information and Documentation of
Francophone India (CIDIF). Hailing from a Tamil family in the former French
colony of Pondicherry, Jacqueline has spent her youth growing up in Indo-China
and Africa, where her father had served as a judge in the French administration.
Roland has just prepared for publication in the public domain of a volume by
Olagnier.
We got to know
Jacqueline and Roland during our 'sabbatical' in Paris from Aug 02 - Jul 03 on
the occasion of the visit and celebration of some 20 Indian writers (Les
Belles �trang�res) to France. We first noticed Jacqueline, when she
intervened forcefully after the round-table with Esther David, Shauna Singh
Baldwin and Nirmal Verma at the Marguerite Durand Library around the theme of
"The inexpressible feminine in Indian writers." However, we got to know each other only at our
next encounter, when we arrived early to listen to readings in English (and
French!) by Shashi Tharoor at the Atelier bookshop on 26 Nov. Discovering in
Roland a remarkable combination of information technology and wide reading in
the humanities, Sunthar found it surprisingly easy to clarify his research on
transgressive sacrality to someone so familiar with French thinkers such as
Caillois, Bataille, Girard. Roland told us especially about the fascinating
researches of their son, Christian. We subsequently ran into them at every other
public event around these visiting Indian celebrities (including Arundhati Roy
at the Sorbonne on Dec. 4). On Dec. 14, they invited us, along with
Jacques Vigne and Shyamala Raja (a
francophone Malaysian friend) to dinner, where we all got to know Christian.
Review of Belles �trang�res visit by 20 Indian
writers to Paris (2002)
Though received from Jacqueline on 1st Jan
2003 and immediately translated from French into English, Sunthar
got around to posting the above review to the Abhinavagupta (and other
related) forum(s) only
21 Sep 2003 (for the reasons explained in the post). See also Sunthar's
first review of 9 Dec 2002, entitled "Multiculturalism,
caste, universalism and the survival of communal diversity: a belated Indian
Thanksgiving," that centers primarily on the exchanges during the
'study-day' on 25 Nov 2002 at the Sorbonne. Before forming your own
assessment, do read the review by Vaiju Niravane (7
Dec 02), who chaired the afternoon session at the Sorbonne, and the
'rejoinder' of sorts by Shashi Tharoor (8
Dec 02), both of which were published in The Hindu. Jacqueline is
currently working on an expanded version of her own review.
This review appeared in
issue no. 28-29 of
"The CIDIF Letter"
Identity, multiculturalism, and laicism
When
Jacques
Vigne visited us at the Benares Hindu University (BHU) in the early 1980s (with
a reference from a common Bengali friend, Jayanti Mishra), he was on a French
Romain Rolland Fellowship working on a book comparing the guru-disciple
relationship in India with the therapist-patient interaction in the West (see
book online in English and French). We had introduced him to our cosmopolitan
circle of friends and scholars in Benares, and he was soon a regular visitor
there. Subsequently, Jacques renounced a top placement to practice psychiatry at
the prestigious St.-Anne hospital and thus a promising career in France in order
to sit at the feet of Hindu spiritual masters, like Swami Vijayananda (himself a
Western doctor of Jewish descent) at Anandamayi Ma's Ashram at Haridwar. Coming
from a devout Catholic background--e.g., he sings medieval Gregorian chants
(sometimes with his brother), and did so at our BHU apartment on the occasion of
Swami Agehananda Bharati's visit--Jacques had also practiced as a psychiatrist
in North Africa, and much of his writings reflect a desire to reconcile the
different approaches of the various (Hindu, Buddhist, Christian, Sufi, etc.)
traditions towards a unifying mystical experience. Moreover, he collaborates
actively with circles of (especially French) psychoanalysts, psychiatrists and
doctors, who are likewise keen to incorporate centuries-old Eastern techniques
of spiritual healing into their clinical practice. Like
Oscar,
Jacques contributes regularly to the Sarasvat� magazine published in Spanish by
the Purusa Foundation. Living in India for more than 17 years now, Jacques spend
most of the year in Himalayan solitude near Rishikish, visiting Europe regularly
to conduct spiritual workshops and guiding groups of Westerners on 'pilgrimages'
to holy sites in India. We were delighted to renew our friendship with Jacques
during his stay in France in late 2002, and have him participate in our recent
session with
Christian on lucid dreaming.
Visit Jacques' home page (articles
in English and French)
Jakob De Roover is a post-doctoral
fellow at the Research Centre Vergelijkende Cultuurwetenschap of Ghent
University. The focus of this
center is the elaboration of
the research program developed by its director, Prof.
S.N. Balagangadhara (Balu). After spending a year studying at Jawaharlal Nehru
University, the secularism debate in India began to fascinate
Jakob: Given the fact that Indian society has been more plural throughout
its history than the West has ever been, why do Indian intellectuals today plead
for the adoption of Western-style secularism?
Research into this issue has resulted
in a PhD dissertation on the historical emergence of
tolerance in Western culture
and the role of the Christian religion in this process. Jakob continues to work
in Balu's research program, which shows that (1) the human sciences have so far
taken place within the Christian religious framework
of the Western culture, (2) the dominant understanding of the Asian and Indian
cultures is constrained by the same framework, (3) alternative theorizing will
give access to the treasure house of knowledge about the human being contained
in the Asian traditions, and (4) it will give a novel perspective on the nature
of Western culture which overturns its
self-understanding.
This text had been put
up earlier on the India Forum website.
Jakob's contribution to the secularism debate was
published as a special article in the Economic and Political Weekly
(28 September 2002).
Dialogues: Hinduism a Religion? does it
exist?
Jayant Kalawar has been (more
of a lurker than) a
participant since 6th January 2002 in our Abhinavagupta
forum. He used to post on
Indictraditions and his posting on shared soteriology had
caught my attention and led me to invite him to join.
A management consultant by profession, Jayant, over the last 30 years, has had
opportunities to consult with American companies all over the USA. His
perspectives, based on intense consulting engagements and interacting with very
diverse groups of people, on Boston brahmins, unrepentant Richmond confederates,
Salt Lake city Mormons, Oklahoma conservatives, Philadelphia Quakers and
Hawaiian Asian-Americans have egged him on to think about what he calls the
American puzzle. Jayant wants to write, as a diasporal insider, about how
Americans see themselves and what drives them to develop certain kinds of
relationships with the rest of the world. He also expects to write about how
Indians look towards and relate to America. His draft essay on Role of Religion
in US-India Relationship is posted on svAbhinava.
Jayant is also currently working on an essay titled A Tale of Two Indians:
Argumentative and Untouchable.
Jeffery D. Long is Associate Professor and Department Chair of Religious
Studies at
Elizabethtown College, in Pennsylvania, USA. Jeff has published several
works on Hinduism and
Hindu identity. He helped organize
6th DĀNAM Conference in 2008; where he was responsible for the Book
Review: Review of Yoga Books and The 'H-Word': Non-Indian
Practitioners and the Question of Hindu Identity sessions, and also
presented on Hindu-To Be or Not To Be: Three Possible Reasons for
Aversion to the Term 'Hindu' among Western Practitioners. He has also
spoken at the
Association for Asian Studies, the
Society for Asian and Comparative Philosophy, and the
American Academy of Religion. He has authored two books, A Vision of
Hinduism: Beyond Hindu Nationalism and Jainism: An Introduction.
He has published articles in
Prabuddha Bharata,
The Journal of Religion,
Science and Spirit, and
Creative Transformation, among others. Long also contributed to the
Hindu American Foundation's "Hyperlink to Hinduphobia: Online Hatred,
Extremism and Bigotry Against Hindus", writing that even "[t]hough it is
less well-known in [the United States], anti-Hindu bigotry is every bit as
ugly and dangerous as
anti-Semitism or
racism, and
every bit as present on the Internet. [adapted from Wikipedia entry]
Published by I.B. Taurus (07 July 2007), 272 pages. [ISBN-10:
1845116267; ISBN-13: 978-1845116262. "Jainism evokes images of monks
wearing face-masks to protect insects and mico-organisms from being
inhaled. Or of Jains sweeping the ground in front of them to ensure that
living creatures are not inadvertently crushed: a practice of
non-violence so radical as to defy easy comprehension. Yet for all its
apparent exoticism, Jainism is still little understood in the West.
"What is this mysterious philosophy which originated in the 6th century
BCE, whose absolute requirement is vegetarianism, and which now commands
a following of four million adherents both in its native India and
diaspora communities across the globe? In his welcome new treatment of
the Jain religion, Long makes an ancient tradition fully intelligible to
the modern reader. Plunging back more than two and a half millennia, to
the plains of northern India and the life of a prince who--much like the
Buddha--gave up a life of luxury to pursue enlightenment, Long traces
the history of the Jain community from founding sage Mahavira to the
present day. He explores asceticism, worship, the life of the Jain
layperson, relations between Jainism and other Indic traditions, the
Jain philosophy of relativity, and the implications of Jain ideals for
the contemporary world. The book presents Jainism in a way that is
authentic and engaging to specialists and non-specialists alike."
"This highly readable book provides an excellent introduction to an
ancient and complex tradition that predates the birth of the Buddha. The
author skillfully explores Jain doctrines regarding the nature of the
soul and the observance of nonviolence, placing Jainism within the
context of Hinduism and Buddhism. He also highlights the influence that
Jainism had upon the life and work of Mahatma Gandhi. The book corrects
misperceptions that have characterized Jain ethics as extreme, and
discusses how Jainism is being practiced globally, including in the US
heartland."--Christopher Key Chapple, Doshi Professor of Indic and
Comparative Theology, Loyola Marymount University, Los Angeles.
"Jeffery Long’s book admirably accomplishes two goals. The first half
of Jainism: An Introduction does exactly
what his subtitle indicates. Long provides a succinct and accurate
overview of the history, beliefs and practices of the Jains that draws
in an excellent manner upon the most recent scholarship. The second half
of the book - in a fine example of the practice of comparative theology
and comparative philosophy of religion - moves beyond description to
engage with what Jainism has to say to anyone living on Planet Earth in
the twenty-first century. In particular, Long is concerned to explore
what the Jain philosophical doctrines of "relativity" can contribute to
the pressing problem of how people respond to the fact of profound
religious diversity. Jainism: An Introduction
will therefore be of interest to anyone interested in the global
religious history of humanity, and additionally to anyone striving to
construct a morally responsible stance on how humans can learn to live
together in all their religious differences. The book will also be a
fine choice for undergraduate students in a variety of fields, including
religious studies, south Asian studies, the history of religion and
comparative philosophy."--John Cort, Professor of Asian and
Comparative Religions, Denison University, and author of Jains in the
World: Religious Values and Ideology in India
Published in Rita D. Sherma and Arvind Sharma, eds., Hermeneutics and Hindu Thought: Towards a Fusion of
Horizons (Springer Netherlands, posted 21 May 2008), pp.179-209 [ISBN: 978-1-4020-8191-0 (Print) 978-1-4020-8192-7 (Online)].
A Vision for Hinduism: Beyond Hindu Nationalism (published Jan 2007, at
Amazon.com)
Published by I.B. Taurus (23 Jan 2007), 275 pages. [ISBN-10:
1845112733; ISBN-13: 978-1845112738. "Two radically different ideologies
are currently competing for the loyalties of the Hindu community. One of
these ideologies, Hindu nationalism, conceives of Hinduness as
co-extensive with Indianness. The other ideology, which has been
articulated by such figures as Sri Ramakrishna and Mahatma Gandhi,
represents Hinduism as the 'eternal' or 'universal' religion. This is an
idea of Hinduism that is pluralistic and all-inclusive. Arguing that
Hindu nationalism is not only destructive of communal relations, but
that it also prevents Hinduism from emerging as a world religion in the
true sense of the term, the author here explores a reconfigured version
of the second of these two ideologies. He presents a vision of Hinduism
as a tradition capable of pointing the way towards a future in which all
the world's religions manifest complementary visions of a larger reality
- and in which they all, in various ways, participate. This radical
religious agenda puts a new and exciting perspective on Hindu and South
Asian studies alike."
Karine is completing her French doctorate in
art history at the University of Paris-IV on the
Iconography of Bhairava in South Indian sculpture (till the XIIIth century).
We were introduced to her (and Krist�le) towards the end of our 'sabbatical'
year in Paris, on 8th July 2003, by David Dubois. Before working in South India,
Karine had also done some research on the iconography of Bhairava in the
Katmandu Valley, which is highly original, hybrid and influenced by (Vajray�na)
Buddhism.
A rather unusual
iconographic type in Indian sculpture, met with in Andhra Pradesh and Tamil
Nadu, shows the god Bhairava furnished with a big club held downwards. This
attribute is more specifically associated with another form of Śiva,
Lakulīśa, considered by some to be an avatāra of Śiva and regarded as
a divine guru by Śaivites like Pāśupatas and Kālāmukhas. In Andhra Pradesh,
where we find the earliest known images of Bhairava with this club, we can
notice some iconographic confusion between Bhairava and Lakulīśa. In Tamil
Nadu – where we hardly meet any Lakulīśa sculpture – images of this
club-handed Bhairava were carved from the Cola period onwards. A new
iconographic form, called CaTTainātar, was then
conceived in the Tamil land. Holding the club in one hand and displaying the
teaching gesture with the other, it shows Bhairava as a god who, at one and
the same time, punishes and teaches, who – just as Lakulīśa who holds his
club to preach the Śaivite faith – is the guardian of śivadharma and the
divine guru showing men the path to salvation.
[published in French in the Bulletin d’�tudes Indiennes, 2002,
n�20.1, p. 163-192 (http://www.math-info.univ-paris5.fr/afei/).]
Professor of English,
Centre for Linguistics and English, School of Language, Literature, and Culture
Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University since 1999. He teaches courses at the M.A. and M.Phil
level and guides doctoral research. His M.A. courses include American
Literature, Indian Literature in English/Translation,
Readings in Literary Theory and Criticism, and M.Phil courses include
Research Methodology and Introduction to Contemporary Literary Theory.
His Ph.D. in English from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign focused
on "Mysticism in Indian English Poetry." Makarand is General Editor of a
series of reprints of rare and out-of-print Indian English titles published by
the Sahitya Akademi, New Delhi, and Editor of
Evam: Forum on Indian
Representations, an international biannual journal. He is also Managing
Trustee of the non-profit Samvad India Foundation. Makarand is a regular guest
speaker or organizer at several conferences, seminars and workshops worldwide.
My introduction to Makarand was through his talk at the
Indic Colloquium on "The
Third Eye and Two Ways of (Un)knowing: Gnosis, Alternative Modernities, and
Postcolonial Futures" (July 25, 2002) reflections
that were explicitly inspired by the writings of Shri Aurobindo. I approached him
thereafter to discuss points of contact between these perceptions and those of
Abhinavagupta. Makarand subsequently visited us in Paris for dinner on 7th July
2003, and even saw me off on the talgo to Madrid the following day. We have
begun collaborating in our publication projects.
Mary Searle-Chatterjee
Mary and I
got to know each other in early 70s, shortly after my taking up residence at
the International House of the Banaras Hindu University, through our
collaboration in organizing lectures on religious culture, particularly
Hinduism, sponsored by the Maharajah at his Chet Singh Palace on the banks
of the Ganga. I was then President of the International Students Union, Mary
would soon be teaching at the Sociology Dept. She has focused on the Muslim
community of Banaras, particularly the weavers (Ansari), who constitute a
quarter of the population of the Hindu sacred city. Mary subsequently
returned to the U.K., where she is now teaching sociology at the University
of Manchester and at the Metropolitan University. Her research has provided
source materials for our monograph Between Mecca and Benares, and we
also facilitated the publishing of her essay on Gh�z� Miy� in Living
Benares (SUNY). We renewed our friendship and intellectual exchanges
over my few days with her (and her colleagues) in August 2001 in the world's
first industrial and working class city. Our discussions on (the Puritan
element in) 'English' national character, stimulated by my visit to the
monument paying tribute to (Manchester's support for) Abraham Lincoln's
war-effort (to the detriment of England's own textile industry!), and my
subsequent discovery of Irish nationalism in Dublin, helped prepare me
mentally for the thesis that the American War of Independence was, in many
respects, a continuation of the English Civil War, and has provided me
valuable insights into the increasing polarization of political debate in
greater Anglo-America with respect to civil liberties and (the impact of)
'globalization' (on developing countries). Most recently, Mary visited
France for the first time to stay with us in Paris from 8-14 Jan 2003,
during which time she got to know
Vinay Bahl, and
also met friends like the Fran�ois Chenet.
Islamicization in a Globalizing Context [1994] - English
This paper was published under the title "'Wahabi' sectarianism among the Muslims of Banaras" in
Contemporary South Asia (1994), 3(2), 83-93. 9/11 of the year 2001 has revealed the
tremendous politico-cultural significance of Wahabism not just for Islam but for the entire world. Mary visited us at the Multiflat Guest House at
BHU in 1986 while researching this paper.
McKim Marriott (PhD, U Chicago 1955) was Professor of Anthropology and of
Social Sciences in the Dept. of Anthropology till he retired in June 1998. He
has researched villagers and urbanites of India and professionals of both South
Asia and Japan. Finding that Western categories often present obstacles to understanding
peoples of these and other areas, he is constructing alternative social sciences
for studying differing cultural realities, using formal modeling and simulations.
[Elizabeth and I were first introduced to Kim by our mutual friend Al Collins in June 2009. We subsequently met not only durin Al's regular visits to Chicago, but also at various, especially South Asia related, events at the University of Chicago. We regularly discuss not only Kim's ongoing theorizing of Sânkhya cosmology and its (continuing) relevance to Indian categories of thought, but also the work of related scholars. - Sunthar (webmaster and editor)]
Before his retirement from
the Indian Foreign Service in December 1993, Mukur had served as India�s Ambassador to Congo,
Chile, Colombia, Cuba and Argentina. I got to
know him as a friend the Ilarraz' in Madrid in July 2001, His views on India's
malaise are particularly interesting because he is a practicing Buddhist of
tribal background. Moreover, as a spiritual orphan of the Partition, his
arguments reflect a lifelong attempt to come to terms with a trauma that
many other Hindu nationalists may have not lived through except in their
imagination.
A Defense of Hindu Revivalism [2001]
Though
Hinduism has been able to assimilate--or at least accommodate--all previous
religions domiciled in the Indian subcontinent, Islam has proved to be the
intransigent exception, resulting in the creation of Pakistan. "What emerges
in all clarity is the opposition between two worldviews with differing
understandings of community, history and the sacred city. Permanent
reconciliation between Hinduism and Islam will be achieved only when—by
reducing the inner distance between Mecca and Banaras—the questions posed by
(the mutilated stump of) the world-pillar—which still straddles the boundary
between the two religions—are finally resolved" (concluding lines of
Visuvalingam, "Hindu-Muslim Relations in Colonial Banaras"). [my comments to
be added...]
Time and Again (Macmillan, India, 2004
- ISBN 1403 92248 9) contains "A reflection on the
long and varied experience of the author as a career diplomat, and a record
of his keen observation on the ways and philosophies of life in many parts
of the world. The protagonist is Arindam Chakma, a
Buddhist from the Chittagong Hill Tracts, now in Bangladesh. He reminisces
his childhood colored by the myths and legends of the tribal folklore of the
Chakmas. The tragedy and trauma of the partition of India in August, 1947
looms large and constantly in his mind. He identifies the root cause as
a conflict of religions between Hinduism and Islam as distinct from a clash
of civilizations."
Indian Community at the Crossroads [2000]
Pinch Yourself and Touch Someone ()
Burhwa Mangal
Oscar Pujol Riembau
Probably the most promising
Sanskrit scholar from Spain, Oscar has been teaching Spanish at the Banaras
Hindu University, where he received his Ph.D. in Sanskrit Grammar in 1999. His
wife, Mercedes, is a Bharata N�tyam dancer, who did her
arangetram
in Delhi in 1999 . She regularly teaches Bharata N�tyam in Mallorca, Spain.
Vasant, his multilingual son, goes to school in Banaras where he was born. Oscar
is currently converting his Sanskrit-Catalan dictionary into Sanskrit-Spanish.
He has published several other books, especially the translation of
Abhinavagupta's Abhinavabh�rat�
on Rasa. Oscar has been very active in promoting cultural exchanges between
traditional Indian and contemporary Spanish/Catalan scholars
(he's currently working on a Spanish text "From the Ganges to the
Mediterranean"). We got to know Oscar and family
shortly before we quit India in early 1989, and we were able to renew our
friendship at his parents' place in Barcelona in June 2001.
During the intervening period, Oscar worked closely on various projects
with F�lix (who subsequently undertook an extended stay in Benares), ending with
a Spanish book on Indian philosophy (in press). He is a prime mover behind the
Fundaci�n Purusa.
Sanskritv�ni website on
Banaras and Indian culture
Check out Oscar's Spanish
Sanskritv�n�
(http://sanskritvani.tripod.com) web-site, sponsored by the Spanish Embassy in
India.
Pathma is a Hindu,
following the Saiva Siddh�nta
path, specifically of the Nandin�tha
lineage (hailing from Rishi
Nandikeshvara, who is the
guru of Tirum�lar), and adheres to
the philosophy of monistic theism
(advaita �shvarapada). Today,
he considers Siv�ya
Subramaniyaswami who initiated him
(d�ksh�),
and his guru Siva Yogaswami of Jaffna, Sri Lanka, as his
own. Pathma, an ex-monk (of
the Kauai �dh�nam,
Hawaii) and a formally trained Hindu teacher,
has been teaching for decades. In addition to ritual
worship, chanting hymns in Tamil,
Sanskrit, and meditating
regularly, he spends eight
hours a day in solitude (as tapas),
socializing primarily with other meditators.
He describes himself as a Hindu evangelist
and today his work is more or less
confined to some teaching, and writing
short articles on Hinduism and on spirituality, most
of which has been posted in the forum at
www.siddha.com.my, his website dedicated to
introducing the basic Hindu beliefs and practices
through the various languages of the world
(about 15 major languages of the world covering four billion people).
He has also been
an occultist, a mantrav�din (Tantric Shaivism), a bomoh (indigenous
shamans of the Malay world),
having studied for many years with teachers in India,
Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia (although
he no longer practices these). Born in 1956 and now
married with two teenage daughters, Pathma is still a
practicing certified public accountant and businessman living
on the outskirts of Kuala Lumpur. He retired
from martial arts, mountaineering, flying, and deep
sea diving long ago.
Pedro
Soto Adrados / Maria Ordu�a Anunciaci�n
Do�a M�
Anunciaci�n Ordu�a Ferrero
(Nunci) and Don Pedro Soto Adrados
are the current President and Treasurer respectively of the Fundaci�n
Purusa. We were introduced by the Ilarraz' on our first visit to Madrid in
Dec. 2000 - Jan 2001, and had the pleasure of getting to know them better on
our second visit to Spain in July 2001. Originally presided over by F�lix
Il�rraz, the Fundaci�n Purusa publishes the Sarasvati journal (East-West
Studies towards a Humanist Renaissance), which features inter-cultural
articles by scholars from all religious traditions. Oscar, a frequent
contributor, had worked on the Sanskrit to Spanish dictionary for a year
under the auspices of the Fundaci�n. Pedro and Nunci are personally involved
with Indian traditions; Pedro was in Benares, Maharashtra and at the
Allahabad Kumbha-Mela in early 2001. Since our first encounter, they have
published several papers in the Sarasvat� journal by Jacques Vigne,
Christian Bouchet, Elizabeth and myself (and more soon by other friends...).
Pedro introduced us (F�lix, Aurora and myself) to Swami Satyananda, a
Spanish monk who lives in Tiruvannamalai, on 13th July 2003 when I last
visited Madrid in July 2003.
Fundaci�n Purusa
web-site and Sarasvati journal - Spanish
"The Purusha
Foundation
was created with the goal of vivifying diverse areas of knowledge such as Philosophy,
Religion, Economics, Sociology,
Art, Poetry, Classical
Languages (Latin, Greek,
Sanskrit), etc., that
contribute in the measure possible to the individual's pursuit of a role
conducive to a New Humanism.
Meaning by the latter an intrinsic relation between
human nature and reason as the supreme fount
helping to discover his/her true nature and
all this in conformity with his/her
personality. Wanting to emphasize at the same time the highest values represented by historical
and traditional
culture, both Eastern and Western, whose
spiritual riches and profundity is unlimited.
This is the sole and transcendental objective pursued
by the Foundation, which has been constituted
under the protectorate of the (Spanish) Ministry
of Education and Culture, and whose vehicle of
expression is the annual publication of a
journal of knowledge named SARASVATI."
Peter Heehs is a historian
based in Pondicherry. He is the author or editor of seven books, most recently
(2002) Indian Religions: A Historical Reader of Spiritual Expression and Experience
(NYU Press). A member of the Sri Aurobindo Ashram Archives and Research Library,
he is part of the editorial team that is bringing out the Complete Works of Sri
Aurobindo in 37 volumes. Peter is the author of the following
books:
Nationalism, Terrorism, Communalism: Essays in Modern Indian History
(1998-2000);
India's Freedom Struggle 1857-1947: A Short History;
Sri Aurobindo: A Brief Biography (1997);
The Bomb in Bengal: The Rise of Revolutionary Terrorism in India 1900-1910
(1996). We were introduced to Peter's work by
Vinay Bahl in Aug. 2003 just after she
had come across his "Shades of Orientalism" (below) and was struck by its
mediating role in our continuing exchanges on the relevance of the 'Abhinavagupta
and the Synthesis of Indian Culture' project to her own socio-historical
approach to contemporary problems in India and the global economy.
Published in
History and
Theory 42 (May 2003), pp.169-195 �
Wesleyan University 2003 ISSN: 0018-2656. "I distinguish six different styles of
colonial and postcolonial discourse about India (heuristic categories, not
essential types), and note the existence of numerous precolonial discourses.
The thought of the early-twentieth-century writer Sri Aurobindo took form in
a colonial framework and has been used in various ways by postcolonial
writers. An anti-British nationalist, he was by no means complicit in
British imperialism. Neither can it be said, as some Saidians do, that the
nationalist style of Orientalism was just an
imitative indigenous reversal of European discourse, using terms like
“Hinduism” that had been invented by Europeans. Five problems that Aurobindo
dealt with are still of interest to historians: the significance of the
Vedas, the date of the Vedic texts, the Aryan
invasion theory, the Aryan-Dravidian distinction and the idea that
spirituality is the essence of India. His views on these topics have been
criticized by Leftist and Saidian orientalists, and appropriated by
reactionary “Hindutva” writers. Such critics concentrate on that portion of
Aurobindo’s work that stands in opposition to or supports their own views. A
more balanced approach to the nationalist Orientalism
of Aurobindo and others would take account of their religious and political
assumptions, but view their project as an attempt to create an alternative
language of discourse. Although in need of criticism in the light of modern
scholarship, their work offers a way to recognize cultural particularity
while keeping the channels of intercultural dialogue open."
(Abstract)
Radhakrishna Warrier is by
profession an electronics communication engineer. Besides science and
technology, his interest spans languages, history,
religion,
philosophy, anthropology, and civilizations.
But he hasn’t proceeded to any level beyond that of an interested layman in
these diverse subjects outside of his professional area of expertise.
Having little time to read and research, the Internet has come as a great boon,
for he has benefited immensely through his
engagement in discussions in internet forums like the Abhinavagupta Yahoo!
group. Entertainment value aside, these
intellectually stimulating exchanges
have exposed him to new ideas, fresh knowledge, and diverse points of
views. After having served his Indian motherland for
about two decades in the capacity of scientist and engineer, the urge to travel
got the better of him, and
he set sail (figuratively) towards foreign lands. After a brief stint in
Middle East, he landed in North America where he continues to live with his wife
and son, the ‘foreign’ land having eventually become his ‘own’ land.
You can see a
picture of Radha with wife Usha here. Radha's childhood environment
till the age of 9 was mostly New Delhi, with
Hindi as much a first language
(along with a smattering of Punjabi) as his native
Malayalam spoken at home. Upon his father's
transfer to Trivandrum in Kerala,
he began rediscovering his roots, attending
a Malayalam medium school where he excelled in all
subjects, particularly in the written forms of his
mother-tongue. His Hindi was quickly revived when as a young man
he went to work in north India. "Whatever
Sanskrit
I know is from mastering
my mother tongue and
through informal inputs from my
mother, father, siblings, and teachers.
If my English is any good, it is
also thanks to my mother and older sisters who took considerable pains to
improve my command over the language."
"I belong to the ‘high’ end of the Ambalav�s�
(temple resident) caste, whose traditional role
was to assist the Nambudiri priest in
performing the public worship, some specific tasks being bedecking
the icon with flower garlands that we string together, preparing the
naivedya (food that is offered to god) within the temple precincts
adhering to all rules of ritual purity, and holding the lamp in the ritual 'pradakSiNa’
(circumambulation) around the temple associated with the
p�j�
rituals. The responsibility of temple administration also fell on my caste
people. The word ‘vAriyam’ in old Malayalam
means an office and a ‘vAriyar’ is an office
bearer, a head of a department. Besides traditional temple duties, the
Warriers (anglicized spelling of ‘vAriyar’)
held important public portfolios under the kings’ rule. They were
ministers, advisors, and teachers to the kings (R�ja guru). They were
well-read in Sanskrit and used to spend a good deal of their time indulging
in literary activities in Sanskrit and Malayalam. Warriers have authored
authoritative works in Ayurveda (traditional medecine),
astronomy / astrology and mathematics in both
Sanskrit and Malayalam. Like the Nambudiri ‘ashTavaidya-s’,
there were eminent ‘�ryavaidya-s’, Ayurvedic
physicians, among Warriers. We were (and continue to be) highly visible in
society as a group of learned people although we form far less than 0.5% of
the population of Kerala. We had good ‘sarasvat�
kaT�kSam’ (side-glance
of the Goddess of Learning)
but perhaps failed to gain enough attention of Lakshmi – we were never very
rich, but fortunately most of us were not very poor either. In short, my
caste people placed great emphasis on learning and education and spared no
efforts in educating their womenfolk. The V�rasy�r-s (feminine of V�riyar)
too were as a rule proficient in Sanskrit and
Malayalam to the extent of being fully able to appreciate and even actively
participate in the literary and other intellectual pursuits of their
husbands. My great-grandmother was tutored in English at home. In Kerala,
our caste was one of the earliest to take to English education and hence was
open to progressive ideas from a very early time. Our family was strongly
traditional but we never clung to anachronistic ideas, superstitious beliefs
and outdated rituals."
Rainer von Grafenhorst
Rainer hat seine Dissertation
(als Dr. phil.) �ber das kosmographische System der Pur�Nas
fertiggestellt, der im Verlag seines
Doktorvaters Albrecht Wezler publiziert
wurde. Das bedeutet nicht, da� ich meine Interessen am alten Indien ganz
aufgegebn habe. Er schreibt
seit einiger Zeit an einem Buch �ber „Wirtschaftsstruktur und Semantik im alten
Indien“. Zur Zeit besch�ftigt er
sich mit dem „Haushalt der Het�re“ bzw. mit dem Thema „Prostitution“.
Meine Quellen sind dharma-, artha- und k�mash�stra-Quellen. Rainer
halt Niklas Luhmann f�r den wichtigsten zeitgen�ssischen Soziologen und ist
von seinem rigorosen Anspruch an saubere Theorie absolut �berzeugt:
nur sie historisches Material wirklich zum Sprechen bringen kann. Ich
habe mich mit dieser Orientierung auch den indologischen Theorien entzogen, die
mir fr�her einmal als besonders vielversprechend erschienen waren, ich erinnere
mich an Dumont, Biardeau und vor allem Heesterman.
Rainer sought me out in ??? on his
arrival in Benares at the recommendation of a friend (Prof. Peter Schreiner). He
soon began to share my own interest in the work of Ren� Gu�non and Biardeau's
anthropology of Hindu civilization. After returning to Europe in ???, Rainer
move to Paris to study French Indology, particularly with Biardeau, and also got
to know Elizabeth's family while we were visiting for the summer from Benares.
In ???, I also met Rainer's wife ???, when I visited him in Hamburg. He
subsequently drove me to Berlin, where Elizabeth came to research Newar
manuscripts on Bhairava at the Preussischer Staatsbibliothek. We got to know
most of his family during this visit. Rainer then also took me to visit
T�bingen, where I got to chat (in German!) with Prof. Heinrich von Stientencron,
pioneer in the iconographic study of the origin-myth of Bhairava, that had
served as the starting point for Elizabeth's totalizing approach to the
mythology of Bhairava in the light of transgressive sacrality. We unfortunately
lost contact with Rainer after moving to the USA in late 1989.
Having
disappeared beyond the horizon since my resettlement in Benares in 1972,
Rajan, my maternal cousin, introduced himself to me as a Unitarian
after my talk on "Death and Sexuality in Hinduism and Islam" at Chicago
University on 2nd April 1991.
He had enrolled
as a Doctor of Ministry candidate in September 1988
at the Meadville Lombard Theological School, Chicago,
and did a
ministerial internship the
following year at the May Memorial Unitarian
Society, Syracuse, New York (where he also go to
know Swami Aghehananda Bharati). Rajan had been living in Indianapolis from
1992 to 1993, just before my taking up a position there in Nov. 93 with
Macmillan Computer Publishing. He had organized a Tagore Festival in
Indianapolis with UU minister, Rev. Larry (and Nancy) Hutchinson (whom I got
to know through Rajan during his subsequent visit to Indy), in which Indian
scholars from Terre Haute had also participated. We met again briefly in
Kuala Lumpur but I subsequently lost track of him again until Oct. 2001.
Raja has worked as a UU chaplain at hospitals in Indianapolis, Fort Wayne
(Indiana), and Austin (Texas). Rajan subsequently visited us in Chicago in
June 2001 and again in Paris in the spring of 2003, and has been
participating in the discussions at the Abhinavagupta forum.
The Holdeen Funds - chapter from thesis on the Unitarian-Universalists and India
Raja
assures me that the references, footnotes, bibliography were thoroughly
checked by a very competent professional librarian who taught the class.
Over and above the religious aspect, it's fascinating to see how Benjamin
Franklin's abhorrence of taxation (shared by other Founding Fathers...)
became Jonathan Holdeen's life mission and the manner in which India's
disinherited have been drawn into this vision...
William Roberts - chapter on the Unitarian-Universalists
and India
The Missionary Paradigm - chapter from thesis in progress
on the Unitarian-Universalists and India
After studying in Delhi's St. Columba's High
School and then St. Stephen's College, Rajiv arrived in the US in 1971 to study
Physics and Computer Science. His corporate careers and business
entrepreneurship included the computer, software and telecom industries. He now
spends full time with The Infinity Foundation, a non-profit organization in
Princeton, New Jersey. Its main interests include fostering harmony among the
diverse cultures of the world. Many of its projects strive to upgrade the
portrayal of India's civilization in the American education system and media.
This involves both challenging the negative stereotypes and also establishing
the many positive contributions from India's civilization.
Visit the
Infinity Foundation homepage
and the Mandala of Indic
Traditions
The common theme underlying most of these
articles and columns are the representations of India, Hinduism in
particular, in the United States (and by extension in the West), as
reflected in and determining academic discourse, mass education, media
stereotypes, foreign policy, etc. In the process, several of them also focus
(at least in part) on the (often maligned) religious values enshrined in
Indian traditions and the socio-political 'unconscious' of American
'multiculturalism'. In addition to the numerous un-moderated comments from
Sulekha readers, several of these essays have been discussed on the Abhinava
forum, either simultaneously (Ganesha, psychoanalysis, critique of history
orientated religions, etc.) or subsequently (caste and racism).
RISA Lila - 2 - Limp Scholarship and Demonology (Nov 17, 2003)
column
Problematizing God's Interventions in History (Mar 19, 2003)
column
The Insider/Outsider Academic Game (Oct 25, 2002) article
RISA Lila - 1: Wendy's Child Syndrome (Sep 6, 2002)
column
The Axis of Neocolonialism (Jul 10, 2002) column
America's Last Chance (Jun 8, 2002) column
A Business Model of Religion - 2 (Apr 24, 2002) column
Hinduism in American Classrooms (Mar 18, 2002) column
The Root of India-Pakistan Conflicts (Feb 11, 2002)
column
CNN's Pakistan Bias (Jan 11, 2002) column
A Business Model of Religion - 1 (Dec 31, 2001) column
How 'Gandhara' became 'Kandahar' (Dec 17, 2001) column
The Asymmetric Dialog of Civilizations (Dec 3, 2001) column
Traditional Knowledge Systems (Nov 19, 2001) column
Gita on Fighting Terrorism (Nov 5, 2001) column
The American Guilt Syndrome (Oct 8, 2001) column
Indian Thought is Not Understood in America (Jul 27, 2001) article
The 'Western Only' Curriculum (Jun 22, 2001) article
Stereotyping Hinduism in American Education (Apr 11, 2001) article
Is There an American Caste System? (Jan 29, 2001) article
Rajiv's open letter of 31 Dec 2003
initiated this dialogue with the Indian Left (FOIL) as represented
especially by academics teaching in the West. Though currently restricted to
an exchange between the two moderators, namely Rajiv and Vijay Raghavan, the
intention is to gradually open the discussion to those intent on
constructive dialogue.
Indic Perspective on Science and
Religion (note)
Satyagraha
against
the academic defamation of Hinduism
(Dec 2003)
Published
on 12 Dec. 2003 (page A30) in response to Paul B.
Courtright's previous piece of ??? Dec
2003 in India
Abroad.
After an early training in Economics, I migrated to Sociology. I am currently pursuing a
doctorate in Sociology from the University of Michigan, at Ann Arbor, Michigan,
and plan to finish in 2005. My areas of interest in sociology are social transformations, citizenship and democracy, demographic
changes and implications for public health and policy, organizational sociology
and global changes due to science and technology. During the last decade I have
become quite skeptical towards ideologies and formulaic thinking. Broadly described,
my research deals with changes in Indian democracy after the 70’s. My
striving in theory and practice is towards the betterment of the lives of
working people of India first and of the world, in that order. Coming from a
small town in Tamil Nadu, India, inevitably my understanding of India is shaped
by social changes in Tamil Nadu during the past several decades. Extensive
travel and work experience in different parts of India have modified my vision,
but the core understanding is perhaps Tamil (vernacular) /small town than
western / cosmopolitan. Long term alternate interests are
cinema (global and Indian), contemporary Tamil literature and critical
thinking in Tamil.
Sanjay Garg is currently Project Manager in the
financial and information technology domain with a focus on financial
derivatives & securitization. Born in Rajasthan and raised in Calcutta & Mumbai,
Sanjay
migrated as a teenager to Canada, has lived in North
America for the past 30 years, and is in a unique
position to act as a bridge between North America & India. Sanjay holds MBA,
BEng., CFP designations with 20 years of progressive
experience with leading global financial services MNCs.
Currently residing in Boston, Massachusetts, he holds
additional professional certifications in information technology, accounting,
investment management & estate planning.
Intellectually,
Sanjay is a product of a (somewhat uneasy?) mix of Marxist thought from his mother's side (maternal
grandfather was a member of CPI-M, Madhya Pradesh) and
traditional
North Indian Hindu practice
of Rajasthan/ Haryana on his father's side. By age 20,
he had read extensively Russian,
British,
French while he was singing bhajan/ kirtans and learning to
play the tabla. As an Advisor with Infinity Foundation since 2002,
Sanjay shares the Foundation's vision of
re-vitalizing the Indic discourse and helping India find its own voice in this
dialogue. He is a member of the fundraising and
selection committees of the recently launched WAVES scholarship initiative.
Sanjay is currently a
member of the Board of Directors of Hindu American Foundation. The Hindu
American Foundation. (HAF) is a registered 501(3)
C non profit organization whose purpose is to provide a voice for the 2
million strong Hindu American community. HAF interacts with and educates
government, media, think tanks, academia and the public about Hinduism and
issues of concern to Hindus locally and globally. HAF seeks to serve Hindu
Americans across all samprad�yas (Hindu
religious traditions).
Sanjay can be heard on RBC radio
in the NY/ NJ/ Connecticut area on Sunday mornings. He interviews scheduled
guests and comments on matters relating to economics, politics. and dharma.
Sanjay has
embarked on a mission to serve the Hindu community substantively first as an
elected executive committee member of the Hindu Society of Manitoba where he
served in successive years as Secretary and Treasurer.
Sankrant Sanu is a software entrepreneur who lives
in Redmond, WA. After working for Microsoft for several years, Sankrant left
Microsoft in 1999 to co-found Paramark, a software company. Sankrant counts the
University of Texas at Austin and IIT Kanpur as his alumni schools. His
interests are varied—from
spirituality to skiing, from computers to playing the congas. Most recently he
has been involved in volunteering as a teacher at a "Hindi school" for kids in
Redmond, and spending some passionate energy conceiving of a plan for rural
education in India. His dream is to dare to live up to the name given to him by
his poet father.
Born in India,
Sitansu has lived in Canada since 1974.
He was teaching philosophy at an undergraduate
college in Calcutta, when
he came to the United States
in 1972 as a graduate student. He
received his M.A. in Philosophy
from Jadavpur Univ., Calcutta,
in 1961; and his Ph.D.
also in Philosophy, from Syracuse Univ.,
NY, in 1977. Teachers to whom he is
particularly indebted are his father, Chintaharan Chakravarti, and
his maternal uncle,
Mahamahopadhyaya Anantalal Thakur, both of them
renowned Sanskrit scholars and manuscriptologists. Their books are in all North
American University libraries where Indic Studies have a place.
Others were Gopinath Bhattacharya, one of the greatest
teachers in modern India of Indian as well as Western Philosophy,
and Pranab Kumar Sen, arguably the best philosopher and teacher in modern
India relating to Western Philosophy. Sitansu was visiting Professor at the Depts.
of Philosophy, Univ. of Rajasthan, Jaipur, 1991, as
well as at Visva-Bharati, Santiniketan,
in 1996. His publications include
Hinduism: a Way of Life,
Motilal Banarsidass, New Delhi, 1991; Modality,
Reference and Sense: An Essay in the Philosophy of Language, Munshiram,
Manoharlal, New Delhi, 2001; Ethics in the
Mahabharata: A Philosophical Inquiry, Forthcoming. He
also has articles relating to Indian as well as Western Philosophy
published in the Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, Journal of the
Indian Council of Philosophical Research, Prabuddha Bharata, or Awakened
India and Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy.
My niece Sumi Sivaratnam left
Kuala Lumpur (Malaysia) in 198? to resettle in Australia. She is currently
completing her doctorate in the classics on Plotinus. She has also taught
Sanskrit. The following 2 articles were published in Dirk Baltzly, Douglas Blyth
and Harold Tarrant, eds., Power and Pleasure, Virtues and Vices
(Prudentia, Supplement 2001, ISBN: 0-9582211-5-4)
TAN CHUNG is an Indian
Citizen of Chinese descent born in Malaya in 1929, having lived, first, in
China for 23 years, and then, in India for 44 years till date. He stepped
into the shoes of his illustrious father, Prof. Tan Yun-Shan
(1898-1983) of Shantiniketan—a
pioneer of Chinese studies in India and Sino-Indian studies—and
contributed to the building up of the Chinese studies programs in Delhi
University and Jawarharlal Nehru University (JNU) from 1964 up till 1994
when he finally retired from JNU as Professor of Chinese. He has been a
Consultant of the Indira Gandhi National Center for the Arts (IGNCA) from
1989 onwards to help develop its East Asian Program. He has authored many
books, among which, China and the Brave New World and also Triton and Dragon
(a Gyan Publication) are text books for history courses in Indian and
foreign universities. His
Dunhuang Art Through the Eyes of Duan Wenjie is a reference book for art
courses on US and other English language campuses. Mrs. Tan has also taught
Chinese at Delhi University. Since 1999,
Prof. Tan and his wife have been living in Chicago with their son.
Valerie J. Roebuck
Valerie J. Roebuck
was born in Hertfordshire, England, in 1950. She found her love for the culture of India at the age of 18, when she visited
her first exhibition of Indian art. She pursued this passion at the University of
Cambridge, where she received a BA Hons in Oriental (Indian) Studies, with Sanskrit as the major subject, and a PhD for a thesis on "South
Indian Bronzes of the Vijayanagar Period". She is
involved in adult education, and is an Honorary
Research Associate of the University of Manchester. Her
translation of the
UpaniSads was published by Penguin Books (New Delhi, India) in 2000 (ISBN: 0-14-044749-0; 503 pages, 395 Rs.).
A new edition for Penguin Classics is due to be published in the UK and USA early in 2003. Previous publications include
The Circle of Stars: An Introduction to Indian Astrology
(Element Books, 1992). She is a Buddhist, practicing and teaching meditation in the Samatha tradition. She is currently the Hon. Secretary of Manchester
Interfaith Forum. She admires the philosopher Giordano Bruno (1548-1600), and is married to Peter Roebuck, an artist.
DR. WILLIAM HARMAN has a Ph.D. from the University of Chicago and served as the Department Head from 2002-2008. He has edited Dealing with Deities: The Ritual Vow in South Asia, which will appear with State University of New York Press in the Fall. Recently, he has published articles on the Hindu Goddess of Fevers, on personal devotion in Hinduism, and on the performance of ritual jokes in a joint Muslim/Hindu festival in India. In the summer of 2004, he wrote a successful grant to take a group of UTC students to India to study Indian culture and religion. He teaches Indian religions, Goddess Traditions, and Introduction to Religions.
The Martyr Bomber Becomes a Goddess:
Women, Theosis, and Sacrificial Violence in Sri Lanka (2009)