Chindia, Russia, Europe: the peaceful rise of Eurasia

From the 3rd millennium BC into the 3rd millennium AD

[Counters temporarily disabled]

[Please read the Introductory notes to svAbhinava Friends all of which apply to these Outreach sites]

Coined recently to capture the growing synergy between China and India, driven now by the rapid convergence of their expanding economies and the simultaneous rise to world-power status of these two modernizing nation-states, the term 'Chindia' is based on mutual perceptions that draw increasingly upon millennial religio-cultural exchanges and profound civilizational complementarities. Though both these ancient worldviews had been inward-looking and convinced of their ethnocentric superiority over the barbarians, they profoundly influenced their neighboring peoples, reshaping their diverse cultures so as to make the label 'Indo-China' an appropriate shorthand designation for the whole of (pre-Islamic) Asia. Imperial China often expanded her borders to counter threats from the north and west, assimilated successive conquerors (Qin, Yuan, Qing, etc., dynasties) into her universalizing Confucian outlook, was acknowledged benign suzerain through regular tribute from vassals as faraway as South-East Asia, and spread her contagious civilizational ethos through the Sinified vehicle of Mahâyâna Buddhism all across East Asia to Japan. Despite her time-tested indigenous socio-political framework held together by the unified state and (its bureaucratic elite sharing a) common written language, China's openness to foreign sources of spiritual inspiration and the accompanying intellectual ferment is best exemplified by her receptivity to and transformation by/of Buddhism. The dazzling success of the Dharma across the whole of Asia contributed as much to the prestige of Buddhism within South Asia as to the efflorescence of Sanskritic culture abroad. India's genius has consisted not so much in proselytizing an intransigent religio-cultural ideology through the force of arms or subtler modes of politico-economic coercion but in repeatedly coming up with creative solutions to her own internal problems of managing and celebrating the proliferation of diversity, paradigms that were universal enough in design, scope, and applicability to be eagerly adopted and adapted by her neighbors as guiding principles for the evolution of their native traditions. Whereas the ideological debate between Buddhism and Brahmanism remained wide-ranging and intense within Indian culture, the otherwise antithetical images of the universalizing renouncer and the ethnocentric intellectual fused abroad to become hardly distinguishable in the figure of composite the Indian sage. That the 'Sanskritization' of so much of South-East Asia occurred without even the knowledge, much less the complicity, of the vast majority of the Indian elite is evidenced by the fact that these foreign lands hardly figured within the Hindu geopolitical imagination (bharata-varSa). Far from resisting Chinese or Indian hegemony, these autonomous centers, exemplified above all by Buddhist Tibet, developed highly original syntheses that served (as more than just two-way conduits) to facilitate the (re-) emerging Chindian matrix. Even as late as the 18th century, when China was at the widest extent of its imperial power, this inter-civilizational dynamic was brilliantly embodied by the Qianlong Emperor, an 'alien' who hailed from shamanistic Manchu tribes that looked up rather towards the Mongols of Central Asia, became wholly steeped in Mandarin culture, owed personal religious allegiance to the Panchen Lama, was revered as a bodhisattva by Buddhists beyond China's borders, accommodated the Muslim sensibilities of his newly acquired Turkish subjects, and was eventually entombed per his wishes in a coffin engraved with Sanskrit prayers.

Sino-Indian reconciliation today amidst lingering tensions from the colonial era has been greatly facilitated and encouraged by the post-Soviet re-emergence of Russia as the key player in the geostrategic equations of Central Asia. Culminating by the dawn of the 20th century, the Slavic pacification of Central and East Asia had already eliminated the threat of invasion by (subsequently Islamized) nomadic Turkic-Mongolian tribes to which Iran, South Asia, and China had always been subject.

While emerging from their common devastation by colonial force of arms, the two nations have had to come to terms with and embrace globalizing modernity through divergent, even diametrically opposed, survival strategies, dictated by their distinctive pre-existent civilization paradigms. Forced to break out of her civilizational isolation

Central Asia, once the perennial home of nomadic threats to the rich sedentary civilizations to the south, was completely pacified by the end of the 19th century by Russia, the (re-) emerging Eurasian power, that now plays a crucial strategic role in providing a security umbrella to the self-determination of India and China, to the extent of becoming a willing facilitator, and beneficiary, in the reassertion of Chindia as constructive force in the creation of a more equitable, multipolar, world-order. [paragraph here on Russia's identity-crisis being torn between the West and Eurasianism]

An overall dynamics of regional confrontation based on seemingly well-founded suspicions of the Other could result in the mutually reinforcing ideological blocs along the following lines: an increasingly xenophobic, militaristic, and expansionist (Han) China, even more oppressive of her own peoples, that would feel obliged to chart out a counter-imperial course against yet modeled upon (its current encirclement by) a unilateral American power that has few scruples about using her neighbors (including Taiwan and Japan) as proxies; a dominating made-in-USA strain of Hindutva pitted against Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, and other 'minorities' only to resemble its Abrahamic nemesis all the more, thereby provoking a million mutinies that spread like wildfire to engulf her neighboring multiethnic and multi-confessional states, and where the celebrated diversity of the 'Hindu' past translates into the irremediable contemporary chaos; a disillusioned post-Soviet Russia that throws in her lot with an encroaching Europe Union in an attempt to survive by steering a mid-course between the trans-Atlantic alliance and the growing conflicts in Asia; in sum an intransigently nationalistic parting of ways that would oblige their Muslim populations to fall back even more uncompromisingly on fundamentalist fervor and make violent common cause with the world-wide Umma; alienated from each other, all three societies will tend to fall apart caught in the indiscriminate crossfire of the "War of Terror" between the West and Islam for global supremacy.

Even while simultaneously ensuring her own geo-strategic security and access to (increasingly scarce) world-resources by systematically courting India's contentious neighbors and extending her reach towards the Indian ocean, China has been actively promoting burgeoning bilateral trade, mutual and joint investments (even elsewhere in the 'Third' World), and the renaissance of shared civilizational memory (such as funding and re-founding the international Buddhist university at Nalanda). Just as a globally re-assertive 'Orthodox' Russia is instrumental in bringing the two rising continental giants closer together within a common Asian security framework, so has 'Confucian' China begun nudging 'Islamic' Pakistan towards a rapprochement over religio-culturally hybrid Kashmir with her fraternal 'Hindu' twin. As the shared (otherwise top-down) political will towards cultural rapprochement, buttressed by economic-cum-security needs, rapidly extends (despite barriers of language, culture and history) to their populations-at-large, the following regional developments may be surmised. Deliberate transformation of an otherwise depopulating (Slavic) Russia under concerted Sino-Indian influence into a beneficent Asian power, a techno-military bulwark against further Western encroachment. Planetary reach of the Chinese dragon's economic-cum-diplomatic clout, both actively facilitated and moderated by Indo-Russian cooperation into a powerhouse for uplifting the material conditions of all subaltern peoples who have yet to free themselves from the 'globalizing' yoke of (neo-) colonialism. Wooing the Indian elephant, with its footprints among the increasingly affluent and assertive Hindu-American diaspora, from a culturally subaltern role in furthering neo-imperial interests into ...

A concerted attempt by this triumvirate of world-powers to peacefully integrate their otherwise recalcitrant Muslim subjects and thereby building and consolidating religio-cultural ties to the Islamic world

This is introduction is still in progress... - SV]


Dialogues

 Who should fear China?  Isolationism, expansionism and harmony (2004-05) [counters temporarily disabled]

ASIA-21 - Futuribles (French)

 Visit the blog and website of Asia-21 think-tank (français) -  (2004-05)

 China on 2020 Horizon (français) - order the book now!

Alain Lamballe [click to see Alain's individual profile]

Counters temporarily disabled

Bhadrakumar, M. K. (Mecca) [click to see Bhadrakumar's individual profile]

Counters temporarily disabled

Catherine Bouchet-Orphelin (Friends, Français)

Counters temporarily disabled

Asia Tomorrow, Continuities and Mutations [external] - book-review , TOC (2005) [counters temporarily disabled]

Relations between South Asia and Europe - in collaboration with Alain Lamballe (français) - (October 2005) [counters temporarily disabled]

Where is China going?  (Où va la Chine ? - français (2000) [external]

China-India, the match of the century (Chine-Inde,  le match du siècle) [external]

 Socrates or Confucius, essay on the future of China and the West (français) [external]

 Asia Rediscovered (L’Asie retrouvée - français) [counters temporarily disabled]

Catherine Chalier (⇐ click to see individual profile)

Counters temporarily disabled

 Emmanuel Levinas in Beijing (French) - May 2004 [counters temporarily disabled]

Dmitry V. Shlapentokh (Athens, Mecca)

Counters temporarily disabled

Check out Dmitry's entire list of publications (24 Aug 2007) [] [counters temporarily disabled]

Intellectual and Political Exchange Among Jihadists: Case of Mustafa Setmarian Nasar (Journal of Applied Security Research, Volume 7Issue 3, 06 Jul 2012)

Lev Gumilev: The Ideologist of the Soviet Empire (History of European Ideas, Volume 38Issue 3, 02 July 2012 )

Russian Elite Image of Iran: From the Late Soviet Era to the Present (16 Sep 2009) - Strategic Studies Institute [counters temporarily disabled]

The Proto-Totalitarian State: Punishment and Control in Absolutist Regimes (2007) - covers, intro, ch. 01, conclusion  [] [counters temporarily disabled]

The French Revolution in Russian Intellectual Life, 1865-1905 [external]

Soviet Cinematography, 1918-1991: Ideological Conflict and Social Reality () [external]

The Rise of the Chechen Emirate?   (Summer 2008; The Middle East Quarterly, pp.49-56) [external]

Wary of China, Russians look West  (24 Jul 2008; Asia Times Online) [external]

Tell-tale travelers' tales: Russia and Iran in the Great Game (17 May 2008; Asia Times Online) [external]

US candidates ride the China bogey  (12 Apr 2008; Asia Times Online) [external]

US enters 'checkbook war' with China  (15 Mar 2008; Asia Times Online) [external]

From local fight to global struggle: Russia's Islamic Threat (01 Mar 2008; Asia Times Online) [external]

Russia's east warms to China  (15 Dec 2007; Asia Times Online) [external]

US loses wattage to China in Iraq (13 Nov 2007; Asia Times Online) [external]

The Russian remodeling of Genghis Khan (11 Oct 2007; Asia Times Online) [external]

The cowboy learns some finesse (18 Sep 2007; Asia Times Online) [external]

CIA: The perils of being a 'good citizen' (28 Aug 2007; ATO) [external]

Obama the realist ... or reckless (21 Aug 2007) [external]

The child of social Darwinism; The Geopolitics Reader (04 Aug 2007; Asia Times Online) [external]

Putin's reading of Solzhenitsyn (25 July 2007) [external]

Iran plays the Azerbaijan card (03 May 2007) [external]

Russia rising: Putin's prods at West belie natural affinity with Old Europe (May 2007) [external]

The death of Russian womanhood (03 April 2007; Daily Times) [external]

The Chinese immigrant experience in Russia (05 March 2007; The Globalist) [external]

The totalitarian streak in the US (01 Mar 2007; Asia Times Online) [external]

America's Opium War (19 Jan 2007; Asia Times Online) [external]

Belarus, another 'axis of evil' candidate (15 Nov 2006; Asia Times Online) [external]

The relevance of Sun Tzu (30 Sep 2006; Asia Times Online) [external]

The first encounter: a different interpretation of the Greek-Persian wars (29 Sep 2006) [external]

China as a US enemy; China: The Gathering Threat by C. Menges (22 Apr 2006; ATO) [external]

Ideology? Don't you believe it; US-China Cold War collaboration 1971-1989 (11 Feb 2006; ATO) [external]

Kissinger, the inconvenient adviser (19 Jan 2006; Asia Times Online) [external]

Putin's war with radical Islamists (08 Mar 2006; Asia Times Online) [external]

Controlling the beast: Exit the Dragon? (23 Dec 2005; Asia Times Online) [external]

The decline of the US economy; Three Billion New Capitalists (17 Dec 2005; ATO) [external]

Driving American foreign policy; The Endgame of Globalization by Neil Smith (08 Oct 2005; ATO) [external]

The Decline of American power; After the Empire by Emmanuel Todd (3/2005; WorldandI.com) [external]

Russia's foreign policy and Eurasianism (02 Sep 2005; Eurasianet) [external]

The Choice: Global Domination or Global Leadership (14 Apr 2005; ATO) [external]

The Georgian Revolution and Caucases Permanent Instability (01 Jan 2004; Straits Times) [external]

The New Anti-Americanism: America as an Orwellian Society (2002; Partisan Review) [external]

Russian Nationalism Today: The Views Of Alexander Dugin   (July 2001; Contemporary Review) [external]

Illusions and realities of Russian nationalism (2000; The Washington Quarterly) [external]

Gautam Sen

 Post-reform China and the international economy (2001; first press) [external]

Makarand Paranjape

 Report on India-China cultural exchange (9th - 16th March 2001) [external]

Martin Riesebrodt

 'Religion': Just Another Modern Western Construction? (December 2003) [external]

Patrick Dombrowsky

Counters temporarily disabled

 A crisis for nothing? - September 2008 (français) [on the Georgia conflict of Aug 2008]

Rajiv Malhotra

Sunthar Visuvalingam

Counters temporarily disabled

Russia-Georgia conflict of Aug 2008: a chronicle of Western propaganda (Aug 2008) [counters temporarily disabled]

Confucian universalism and Manchu differentialism: the Qianlong Emperor (2004-05) [counters temporarily disabled]

Dialogues (Fear China? )

Tan Chung (Friends)

Counters temporarily disabled

Vinod Saighal

Counters temporarily disabled

Why Sonia Gandhi could never have become Prime Minister (May 2007) [counters temporarily disabled]

The stand-off on the Iranian nuclear issue (15 Dec 2006)  [external]

Demands of Demography, Democracy, and Strategic Considerations (Feb 2005)  [counters temporarily disabled]

The Search for Global Solutions - From Awareness to Action (September 2004) [counters temporarily disabled]

 Global Security Paradoxes 2000-2020 (2003) reviewed by Ajoy Bagchi [counters temporarily disabled]

 Role of International Community in Demilitarization of Tibetan Plateau (2002) [counters temporarily disabled]

 The Dalai Lama: The Man and his Vision [counters temporarily disabled]

 Dealing with Global Terrorism: The Way Forward (about the book & TOC) [counters temporarily disabled]

 Restructuring Pakistan (Dawn review ; Interview in Pakistani Press) [counters temporarily disabled]

Wang Dehua

Yin Xi'nan

Counters temporarily disabled

Visit Yin's Faculty homepage at the Institute of South Asian Studies, Sichuan University [external]

Tagore's various responses in modern Chinese intellectual circles in the 1920s (October 2011) [counters temporarily disabled]